FOR YOU
Failure is not a verdict. It’s data.
Tuesday, four o'clock. A colleague treats everyone to cake for her birthday, and you had promised yourself: no sugar this month. Just one slice, you think. That won't hurt.
In the evening, the biscuit tin is open. The day is already ruined anyway. And as you grab the last biscuit, you make a decision: Monday I'll start over. Really.
Sound familiar? Then you're in good company. That single slice of cake was never the problem. What you make of it afterwards, that's where the issue lies.
One misstep, and the whole plan goes overboard
Psychologist Alan Marlatt studied how people relapse for years, and he saw the exact same pattern every time. The misstep itself doesn't trigger the relapse. The conclusion we draw from it does. "See, I just don't have any willpower." Anyone who thinks like that sees a slip-up as proof. And why would you still bother trying if the verdict has already been handed down?
In popular terms, that's called the what-the-hell effect. One slice of cake turns into a box of biscuits. One skipped workout turns into a gym membership that sits sleeping in your wallet for three months.
Why we learn so little from failure
You would think that failure would at least teach us something. Ayelet Fishbach and her colleagues at the University of Chicago looked into it. In their experiments, people learned less from what went wrong than from what went right. Unless it was someone else's mistakes, because they learned just as much from those.
The difference lies in our ego. Failure feels like a judgment on who we are, so we look away. We want to forget it as quickly as possible, and that is precisely how we throw away the most valuable information.
And then we wait for Monday
What follows is almost always the grand fresh start. Next week, next month, after the holidays. Researchers at Wharton led by Katherine Milkman observed in Google search data that queries for "diet" consistently spike at the start of a week, a month, or a year. They call it the fresh start effect.
A fresh start like that brings energy, and that's good news. But whoever waits for Monday after every slip-up loses a few days each time. You can already adjust your course tonight.
Read your failure like a pilot
A pilot who spots a deviation on their screen doesn't panic and doesn't look for someone to blame. They read the signal and make an adjustment. A few degrees, usually that's all it takes.
I learned that with our first restaurant. Poor location, loss-making, months of stress and tears. We were faced with a choice: quit or reinvest. We opted for the latter, but not blindly, because the data was on the table. First lesson: your location makes or breaks your business. In Leuven, we went for right in the city centre, where people walk past all day long. Second lesson: know what you are. We dropped the evenings and opened seven days a week, with specialty coffee and trendy brunch. And we kept operations simple, so we became faster and more consistent. Today, business is thriving in Leuven. Not because we worked harder, but because we redesigned smarter.
How to turn failure into data
Ask yourself three questions after a slip-up. Preferably right away, and not just on Monday.
What exactly happened? Only the facts. "At four o'clock, at the office, on an empty stomach" tells you much more than "I'm weak".
What made it difficult? Look for it in the situation, not in your character. Tired, hungry, stressed, and the cake was within arm's reach. Those are dials you can adjust.
What is the smallest adjustment? An apple in your bag for the afternoon slump. Or deciding in advance that you'll have half a slice when there's a treat and simply enjoy it.
And in your team?
Teams work the same way. Where mistakes are punished, people will hide them, and then the very information you need to make adjustments disappears. The good news from Fishbach's research: we learn easily from others' mistakes. So a team that openly shares what went wrong learns together what each person individually would rather forget. Try it in your next team meeting: bring one misstep to the table, go through the three questions, and make sure nobody gets the blame.
The difference between people who change and people who get stuck doesn't lie in how often they fall. It lies in how quickly they bounce back.
Failure isn't a verdict. It's data.
Think of your last slip-up, and ask yourself those three questions today. What will you do in the second that follows?