FOR YOUR ORGANISATION
A fine is a price
Haifa, late 1990s. A day-care centre closes at four o'clock, but every week parents arrive late. The teacher waits, coat already on, next to a child looking at the door.
Management steps in, as any good manager would. From now on, anyone more than ten minutes late pays a fine. Clear rule, clear consequence.
The number of late arrivals almost doubled.
What went wrong
Economists Uri Gneezy and Aldo Rustichini tracked the experiment across ten day-care centres. Their explanation fits into a single sentence: a fine is a price.
Before the fine, parents felt guilty towards the teacher. Being late was simply not done. With the fine, it became a service you could buy. Ten minutes of extra care for a small fee. The guilt was gone.
And when management abolished the fine after a few months, parents kept showing up late. The rule was gone, but the new meaning remained.
Sound familiar?
I saw it happen myself. At a company I managed, every employee received one of our products to try out for free. In return, we asked for two things: an online review, and feedback for the marketing team. Whoever failed to do so wouldn't receive a free test product the following year.
Hardly anyone wrote a review.
In hindsight, it makes sense. We had turned a favour into a transaction, with a price everyone knew. No review? Then no product next year. For most people, that was a fine deal.
Organisations do this every day. A fine for arriving late to a meeting, a penalty if targets aren't met, a stricter procedure after every mistake. People start calculating: what does it cost me, and is it worth it? What used to happen naturally, out of enthusiasm or respect for a colleague, turns into a trade-off.
What does work: the path of least resistance
The alternative is not laissez-faire. It is design: you don't punish undesirable behaviour after the fact; you make the desired behaviour the easiest path from the outset.
An American company once changed just one thing about its pension plan. New employees no longer had to enrol themselves: they were enrolled automatically, and anyone who didn't want to participate had to opt out. Economists Brigitte Madrian and Dennis Shea saw participation among new hires rise from about a third to more than four out of five. No reward, no sanction. Just a different default.
Now imagine that same product test differently. With the product comes a QR code that leads straight to the review page, with your name already filled in. And the feedback for marketing? That can just be informal, by the coffee machine or during the lunch break, to whoever happens to be there. No form, no deadline, just trust. I'd wager the reviews would have come in then.
Three questions for your next team meeting
Which rule in our organisation has turned into a price? Look at the sanctions you use, and whether people still feel them as a punishment, or simply as a cost.
How do we make the right behaviour the easiest path? A default, a shorter route, a fixed slot in the calendar.
What made it difficult the last time things went wrong? That's your leverage, and you'll find it in the system, not with the person to blame.
And for yourself?
We like to resort to punishment with ourselves, too. Missed a workout? Then an extra-long one tomorrow as penance. It works just as poorly as in Haifa. Lay out your running shoes and put your mobile in another room. A low threshold achieves more than a harsh punishment.
Design the path. Not the punishment.
Which rule in your organisation has actually become a price? And how do you make the desired behaviour the path of least resistance?